Cat’s Out of the Bag

jayde

ATTORNEYSCOTT COMMENTARY:

A tale of two cats, sovaldi sale or four to be more precise. Designer Jayde Hilliard created a series of pieces she entitled, decease “Blue Willow Menagerie” that depicted animals embellished with the public domain Blue Willow pattern. Pleased with her work, sales she posted it on Deviant art, where it can be seen below:

jayde

 

To her chagrin, the cat aficionados over at Bradford Exchange thereafter posted a product that bore a certain resemblance to her prior work. See below:

bradford

 

Comparing the pieces, though, reveals a close call as to the question of whether the idea was taken (still legal, recall that ideas are “as free as the air,” according to at least one judge), or if the expression was lifted (a violation of the Copyright Act). At the very least, it is a dispute that gives us paws.

-AttorneyScott / scott@copyrightLA.com

Posted by AttorneyScott  |  1 Comment  |  in Uncategorized

One Comment

  1. CrossTheLime 06/09/2015 3:54 pm

    Pssst – the piece wasn´t just up on Deviantart, but the artist actually *applied* with that portfolio piece to that exact same company. Funny how things then turn out, right?

Post a Comment

  • What is this place?

    YTWWN is a blog where users have taken notice to a blatant rip off of a creative work, and shared it with us. Sharing and discussing the observations and casualties of improper use of creative property is what we're all about here.

    This is an open blog, so please, add to and join the discussion, but keep in mind that there is a fine line between a rip-off and similarity of ideas. Please read the 'About' page before posting.

    Please use some discretion before posting to help us keep this blog legitimate.

    We look forward to seeing what you have to share.